Caleb smiled when she not only understood what he was trying to get at but actually went along with it. His hands rested on her legs as they sprawled across his lap, his hands alternating in caressing them. The ceiling faded behind his eyelids as soon as she began playing with his hair. He loved when she did that.

When her fingers began to roam further, he did everything he could to try not to let it turn him on too much. She was being intimate, didn't mean it had to lead to anything more. He needed a definitive green flag before he let the second head between his legs win against the one on his shoulders.

'Cold weather. Naked in the cold. Alice Mae naked in the cold. Damnit no! Dick in the snow cold.' Caleb opened his eyes in an attempt to stop picturing his girlfriend naked. He looked over at his fully clothed girlfriend and it would have helped if she hadn't used her finger to outline his lips. That sent his mind racing with a number of dirty thoughts.

Then she kissed him. Caleb did his best to not seem too eager in his response, but still enough to let her know he desired her in that way always. Her words of approval were all he needed to deepen the kiss. One of his hands left her leg in search of the back of head while the other worked it's way up her thigh and to her hip. Once there he pulled her in closer before continuing it's adventure up to her chest.

One of Alice Mae's hands instinctively shifted to the back of his head and entangled in his hair after he deepened the kiss and pulled her closer. She moaned softly against his lips, feeling his hand slip underneath her top and brush against her skin. As eager as she wanted to be right now, Alice Mae wished to keep their pace slow. She enjoyed the fourplay just as much as she did the sex, and right now, she was trying to savor every moment she could.

After making out for several more minutes and Caleb’s hand freely roaming underneath, Alice Mae began wanting more. That's when she broke their kiss and swiftly removed her t-shirt and panties and tossed them on the floor next to the couch. Alice Mae laid back, pulling Caleb with her. She opened her legs more as he tried to settle in between them comfortably. Once they were situated, the pair quickly returned to where they had left off. Alice Mae’s hands found their way into Caleb's luscious hair again, and every time his hands moved over a sensitive part of her body, she would tug gently.

Her tongue steadily moved in and out of Caleb's mouth. Her hands moved from his hair, and rested on his shoulders. As much as she liked to be in control of all situations, tonight was different. Alice Mae wanted to follow her boyfriend’s lead.

Caleb whined slightly when she pulled away, not ready to be done yet, but when he opened his eyes and saw her stripping down, he wasted no time following suit. He yanked his shirt off and tossed it across the room, but failed to get his boxers off before Alice Mae pulled him down on top of her. It was probably for the better, as much as he wanted her right now, he had to make sure she got hers and the foreplay was a big factor in that. With just a thin layer of material remaining between them, it made it slightly more easy to hold off for longer.

Every tug of his hair was met with an involuntary thrust from his hips. Caleb could feel his boxers becoming damp between them as he continued to rub her most sensitive area with his erection and they passionately make out. His urge to enter increased as well and he had to remember to slow himself down. She needed the release more than he did.

The moment that she let go of his hair, Caleb's kisses began trailing to her cheek, then jaw, before resting on her neck for a moment. Only long enough to give a nibble before continuing down toward her chest. Once he reached her nipples, he swirled his tongue around one and cupped the other breast with his roaming hand. Caleb scooted away from her just enough to make room for his other hand to slide in between her legs.

Alice Mae turned her head to the side as Caleb trailed away from her mouth, pressing her fingertips into his shoulder blades as he made his way down her. Once he reached her belly button, Caleb began shifting his body down until his head was between Alice Mae's thighs. He then wrapped his arms around her thighs, pulling her closer to his face.

She gasped as Caleb penetrated her for the first time with two fingers, her back arching slightly as he steadily moved them in and out of her. Alice Mae bit her bottom lip to avoid making too many noises while his fingers continued to explore inside of her. Then, Caleb replaced his fingers with his tongue, licking and sucking avidly on her clitoris, occasionally slipping a finger or two into her. As the sensation intensified, Alice Mae was no longer able to stay quiet. She moaned, cupping one of her breasts before playing with her nipple.

"Wait, wait, wait," Alice Mae cried out. She wanted Caleb to stop before he made her climax. She lifted her head to look down at him, "I want to cum with you inside of me," she informed him. "I want you to feel it." Caleb eagerly removed the last of his garments, tossing them on the floor with the rest of their clothes. They stayed in the same positions, except Caleb was now on his knees as he worked on closing the space between them.

Caleb loved hearing her moans and feeling her squirming increase as he ate her out. He also loved the taste of her, he'd gone down on his share of girls, but she was by far the best. His eyes snapped open the moment he realized why she'd stopped him, and quickly thereafter his boxers were gone. Caleb positioned his penis at her entrance but waited before thrusting. Quickly moving his hand out of the way and back on the couch to get better leverage, Caleb looked down at her and placed one soft kiss on her lips. "I love you," he reminded her.

Taking his time with the first thrust, his eyes closed as he enjoyed the feeling of her walls surround his dick. Going until he could go no further, a low groan escaped his lips. Caleb continued kissing her as he picked up pace with his thrusts, making sure to let her feel the full length of him every time. Once she began bucking her hips up in rhythm with him however, he could feel the pressure building inside of him. Positioning himself to support his weight on one arm, his now free hand latched onto her hip as he pushed as deep as he could into her.

Pressed close and his movements longer as expansive, his body rubbed against her clit with each swift thrust. Caleb's fingers pressed into her skin as he continued to pump into her until he felt her reaching her climax again. This time she let him get her all the way there, soon he felt her walls tighten around and her nails dig into his back. Not long after, Caleb let out his own loud moan and he combined his cum with hers.

Alice Mae had never been with anyone other than Caleb. He was her first, and she was hoping he'd be her last too. So, everything she knows, Caleb taught her.

She could feel the tip of his penis at the entrance of her vagina as he leaned forward to kiss her. "I love you too," she replied softly before letting out a soft gasp when Caleb swiftly slid into her, making sure she felt everything. As Caleb caught his rhythm, Alice Mae began thrusting upward and meeting every one of Caleb's thrusts into her. She moaned, clutching onto his back. "Go deeper," she begged and nibbled on his earlobe briefly.

She felt the sensation build in between her legs as Caleb began to pick up his pace. With every one of his thrusts, Alice Mae's fingertips dug deeper into his back as she cried out. It was enjoyable and painful at the same time. Yet, she didn't want him to stop. Alice Mae opened her legs as wide as possible, wanting to ensure she got all of Caleb. Alice Mae kept one hand on his lower back and moved the other to the side of his face, cupping his cheek. Alice Mae stared into his eyes, whimpering every time he went too deep.

Alice Mae could not get off with a simple few penis thrusts like most girls her age. Instead, she needed constant stimulation against her clit and was lucky enough to have a boyfriend who knew how to do that. Alice Mae let out a mixture of moans and cries as Caleb continued hitting her spot, finally causing her to climax. Her fingertips dug into his back while her other hand fisted a handful of his hair at her peak. Ultimately, Alice Mae could feel the walls of her vagina open and close around Caleb's thick penis as he moved in and out of her raw. Despite Caleb's constant begging, they only had sex a few times without condoms, and that was because she was terrified of getting pregnant before being married. She had to admit, though, the sex was always better when they didn't have one.

After Caleb hit his peak, he collapsed on top of Alice Mae while trying to catch his breath. Embracing him, she pressed a quick kiss against his forehead before letting her head fall back against the seat cushion. She could still feel the aftermath of her orgasm and was too numb to move. Alice Mae closed her eyes while one of her hands started to move up and down his back as the other played with his accessible earlobe. It was a good thing he was okay with her unnecessary fidgets.

As much as she didn't want to, she knew they'd have to move. They still had a few hours before the bars closed, but she didn't know if her mother would come home early. That'd be embarrassing and awkward if she were to walk in on them. "You wanna go to bed?" Her fingertips softly moved over his cheek and jawline. "Or at least move this to my bedroom," Alice Mae suggested with a chuckle.

Caleb couldn't focus on anything except how amazing it felt fucking Alice Mae. Most high school girls really just laid there and didn't do much at all - they must have figured it was all his job once he was inside of them. There had been a couple of girls that were crazier but with them he also risked bodily injury and it really hadn't been worth it. Caleb was like Goldilocks and Alice Mae fit him just right. He also figured that he could always sneak in some new things slowly with her every now and then so that things never got boring.

"I wanna sleep right here," he joked, knowing that wasn't possible. Grunting as he struggled slightly to lift the weight of himself off of her. Looking down at her with a smile, he gave her a kiss on the tip of her nose before snagging his boxers off the ground to use them to prevent any juices from falling out onto the couch when he pulled out. Once separated, he used them to clean her up (then himself) enough to be comfortable on her trip to the bedroom. "I got the clothes, you just get your cute butt back to the bed." Caleb was hoping to get in some more naked cuddling in.

Tossing his boxers in her bedroom trash, he placed her clothes on the ground next to her side of the bed before climbing his way into his side. Wrapping an arm around her, he pulled her in closer as she rested her head on his chest and got comfortable. Slowly stroking her hair once she finally situated, Caleb looked down at her and smiled. "I love you, Alice Mae."

"Thank you," Alice Mae sweetly said, watching as he wiped down her body with his boxers. She thought it was sweet. Once getting off the couch, Alice Mae nodded with a grin, "Yes, Sir," was the last thing Alice Mae said before disappearing up the stairs. She wanted to clean herself off a bit more and use the bathroom. When she was done and returned to her bedroom, Caleb was already on his side of the bed. She shut the door behind her and wasted no time climbing into bed, snuggling up to him.

She rested her head on his chest before entangling her legs with his. Her eyes closed as Caleb started to stroke her hair. Alice Mae shifted when he repeated her three favorite words. She tilted her head back, looking up at him, "I know you do, Caleb," she sleepily smiled at him. "And I love you," she said, snuggling closer and pressing a kiss against his chest. "Your arms are the only ones I ever want to fall asleep in." It was crazy to think about because they were so young, but Alice Mae knew Caleb was her end game. Especially after everything that has happened in the last few days. He never left her side.

She was sleepy enough to fall asleep, but she also didn’t want to miss this moment. Her hand moved over Caleb’s chest, connecting his beauty marks again while he played with her hair. After a few moments, she moved on top of him, much like he had been while they were downstairs, but more carefully so she didn’t hurt anything important. “What was your very first ever thought about me?” Alice Mae curiously asked, placing her hands one over the other on his chest before resting her chin on them. “I nearly pissed my pants the first time you spoke to me after the game,” Alice Mae reminisced. “I heard you’d been asking about me, but I only thought they were rumors until then,” she admitted.

After their activities downstairs, Caleb was ready to sleep the night away but unfortunately his girlfriend wasn't quite as ready yet. When she climbed on top of him, he almost thought she was ready for round two but quickly realized that this was more so aftercare for her. "My first thought?" he repeated, giving himself a moment to replay the first time he'd thought about her like that. He had first noticed her when she became a cheerleader but that was purely in a sexual all-cheerleaders-are-hot kind of way. It wasn't until he saw her stand her ground and shut down one of his teammates that he realized she was more than just a hot set of pom poms.

"Honestly?" he asked even though he already knew what her answer would be. Caleb interlocked in his fingers behind his head and looked at her with a smirk. "I thought you were fuckin' hot." His eyes may have fallen for her first, but it didn't take long for his heart to do the same. The more time they spent together and the more he got to know her, the more he realized that he didn't need anyone else. And that was why he would never intentionally flirt with any other girl but her.

"Then I realized you were the whole package and I had to shoot my shot. You think you were nervous though? I was terrified you were going to tear me apart like you did to Eric when he tried to hit on you," he joked with a chuckle. He debated asking her the same thing but, considering he'd still been a bit of a player when she first noticed him, he decided to change it up a little bit. "What was it about me that made you say yes?"

Alice Mae rolled her eyes at him when he initially answered, "I should've known," she muttered. But then he continued, and she chuckled when he mentioned Eric. "That's because Eric is gross and has STIs," she pointed out. "He gave like three cheerleaders chlamydia. That's why I said no," she said, gagging.

"I heard you were a nice guy despite your track record," Alice Mae told him. "Your looks didn't hurt your chances either," she said playfully, sticking her tongue out at him. "To be honest, I had a crush on you long before you knew I existed," she explained. "One of the varsity cheerleaders you were fucking around with used to make fun of me for it." Alice paused, wondering if she had said too much. The only person who knew all of this was Heather. It was something she had never expected to tell Caleb. "I said yes to spite her, but I also said yes because you were my dream guy, and you didn't even know it."

"That didn't go as expected, huh?" Alice Mae chuckled, but she didn't want Caleb to dwell on one of his past fuck buddies giving her a hard time. Because, of course, Alice Mae wasn't thinking about that situation anymore. In her eyes, she won. She was co-captain of the varsity team with Heather and got the quarterback. Who treated Alice Mae the way Leslie could only have wished.

She shifted her body downward, spreading open Caleb's legs before settling in between them. Alice Mae wanted to distract him from the thoughts she unintentionally put there. So, she stroked his penis with one hand while the other played with his balls to get him hard. She didn't even know if it'd be possible since she knew he was probably just as tired as she was.